Buying stocks with borrowed money isn’t as crazy as it sounds

image

If borrowing money is so cheap, and the returns from stocks are so good, why shouldn’t we borrow money to buy more stocks?

That at least is the apparent reasoning of CalPERS, America’s biggest pension fund, which has just announced it hopes to goose up returns by taking on debt so it can buy more investments on margin.

The amount so far isn’t much: CalPERS says it will borrow up to 5% of the value of its portfolio, although it says it may in time raise that to 20%.

But it raises the intriguing question: Why don’t we all do this?

It’s not like borrowing is expensive. federal funds rates are basically 0%. Even amid the current flap about inflation, they are predicted by the money markets (rightly or wrongly) to rise to no more than 2% by 2025. BofA Securities points out that interest rates on 10 year Treasury bonds are now nearly 5 percentage points below current inflation, “a level in the past 200 years that has been associated with panics, inflation, wars & depression.”

No, you and I can’t borrow at the federal-funds rate. On the other hand, middle-class Americans often have access to multiple sources of pretty cheap debt which we could, if we wanted, use to take on extra investments. Some are obvious: Home equity lines of credit, margin debt at your broker, and those 0% credit card offers flying into our letter boxes like invitations from Hogwarts.

Some brokerage firms charge usurious interest rates on margin but others don’t. Interactive Brokers, for example, charges as little as 1.58%.

And there are other alternatives as well. Stock options, financial instruments that are complex but less ‘dangerous’ than they sound, effectively let you buy $2 or $3 or even $10 worth of stocks with $1 down at reasonably low cost. Closed-end mutual funds, a type of fund that is structured like a regular stock and which trades on the market, often use cheap debt to boost their returns. And there are “leveraged” exchange-traded funds, usually with names like Ultra or 2X or 3X, that effectively try to get you more investment bang for your buck. All come with massive caveats and risk warnings, but they aren’t always exploding cigars.

Oh, and if you delay paying your federal taxes until the due date, April 15 of the following year, you will have the extra cash all year for investment and Uncle Sam will currently charge you just 3% for the privilege.

According to data from NYU’s Stern School of Business, since the 1920s the returns on the S&P 500 have beaten the returns on Treasury bills by an average of 6.5 percentage points a year.

Borrowing to invest isn’t as crazy as it seems, either. After all, what do we all do when we buy a home? We typically put down just 20% or 25% of the value and borrow the rest. Nobody thinks this is insane. And it is the main source of wealth for many middle-class people. Think of how much money you’ve made on the value of your home. Imagine how little you would have made if you had not been able to take out a mortgage, and instead had only been able to buy a home when you could afford 100% of the purchase price. You’d still be renting, and the poorer for it.

Warren Buffett invests with leverage. Some years ago, analysts found that the main source of Buffett’s stunning investment success over many decades was neither superior stock selection, market timing or management skill: It was simply that he borrowed money cheaply, through his insurance operations, and using the extra money to buy more stocks than he could otherwise. He focused, they worked out, on stocks that were cheap, high quality, and had low volatility. Meanwhile his leverage, they calculated, averaged 1.7:1. In other words, he ran his portfolio with the equivalent of a 60% mortgage.

Allan Mecham, the boy wonder who ran Arlington Value investments for 20 years, went a step further some years ago: Through his fund he borrowed money cheaply to buy extra stock in Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway, boosting his investors’ returns even more.

Some financial experts argue that we should borrow money to invest when we’re young: Otherwise we invest too little in our 20s and 30s, when we don’t have much money, compared with what we can invest in our 50s and 60s.

There are obvious downsides to the concept of borrowing money to buy stocks. The first is that the best time to do this probably isn’t when scribblers like me are writing about it. The market right now is at record highs, and by various calculations may be in a massive bubble that is ripe for a nasty fall. The late economist Hyman Minsky famously argued that when things are booming people get complacent, borrow too much and take on too much risk, which creates the next crisis. You could consider articles like this — and actions like those of CalPERS — as a Minskyesque warning.

Margin debt at brokerage firms is already at record levels, and is nearly twice what it was just a few years ago. The best time to borrow money to buy more stocks is going to be during a collapse, when stocks are cheap, fear stalks the land… and hardly anyone wants to take on risk.

The second problem with borrowing money to buy stocks is that you should only do it if you are absolutely sure that you can ride out the extra volatility. In the last two major bear markets, from 2000 to 2003 and 2007 to 2009, the S&P 500 halved in value. Someone running a portfolio with 50% borrowed money would have been wiped out.

Too many people owning too many stocks with too much borrowed money is precisely what made the infamous 1929 stock market crash so deep and so bad.

By 1932, incidentally, stocks had fallen 90% from their peak. Ouch.

In theory there is nothing wrong with borrowing a modest amount to buy more stocks, as we do to buy our homes. Even, say, borrowing an extra 10% or 20% could add materially to long term returns. But only if you are sure you can ride out the volatility. Otherwise you will end up losing, not winning, from the trade.

Trending Ideas

Featured Stocks On The Move

Daily Rundown

Top 3 Stocks in Leading Sectors
  • 3 Electric Power Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Hawaiian Electric Industries, Inc. (HE) Hawaiian Electric Industries, Inc. is a holding company that provides electric utility services and financial services in Hawaii. Through its subsidiaries, it supplies... Read More

  • 3 Bank Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Comerica Incorporated (CMA) Comerica Incorporated is a financial services company headquartered in Dallas, Texas, offering a range of banking products and services, including commercial and retail banking, wealth... Read More

  • 3 Machinery Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Alta Equipment Group Inc. (ALTG) Alta Equipment Group Inc. is an integrated equipment dealership platform in the United States, operating through three segments: Material Handling, Construction Equipment, and... Read More

  • 3 Silver Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Gatos Silver, Inc. (GATO) Gatos Silver, Inc. is a precious metals mining company primarily focused on silver and zinc production. Its flagship Cerro Los Gatos mine in Mexico... Read More

  • 3 Metal Production Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Century Aluminum Company (CENX) Century Aluminum Company is a primary aluminum producer, with operations that include the production of high-purity, low-carbon aluminum used in automotive, aerospace, and industrial... Read More

  • 3 Medical Drug Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Limited (TEVA) Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Limited is a global pharmaceutical company specializing in generic and specialty medicines. The company provides a wide range of treatments... Read More

  • 3 Paper Product Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content AptarGroup Inc. (ATR) AptarGroup Inc. is a global leader in providing innovative dispensing and packaging solutions, serving diverse industries like beauty, personal care, and pharmaceuticals. They focus on... Read More

  • 3 Restaurant Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Brinker International, Inc. (EAT) Brinker International, Inc. operates well-known restaurant brands such as Chili’s Grill & Bar and Maggiano’s Little Italy. The company is a leader in the... Read More

  • 3 Investment Brokerage Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Robinhood Markets, Inc. (HOOD) Robinhood Markets, Inc. is a financial services company known for its commission-free trading platform, which allows users to trade stocks, options, cryptocurrencies, and ETFs.... Read More

  • 3 Shipping Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content ZIM Integrated Shipping Services Ltd. (ZIM) ZIM Integrated Shipping Services Ltd. is a global container shipping company that provides cargo transportation services worldwide. The company operates a modern... Read More

  • 3 Mining Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Perpetua Resources Corp. (PPTA) Perpetua Resources Corp. is a mining company focused on the exploration and redevelopment of the Stibnite Gold Project in Idaho, which is one of... Read More

  • 3 Airline Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content General Electric Company (GE) General Electric Company is a global industrial conglomerate with operations spanning sectors such as aviation, healthcare, power, and renewable energy. GE is known for... Read More