Wall Street’s ‘Model Portfolio’ Boom Gets Slammed in New Paper

image

(Bloomberg) — A booming $4.9 trillion branch of the U.S. asset management industry is funneling investor cash into funds that are pricier and worse-performing than alternatives, new research claims.

So-called model portfolios — off-the-shelf investment strategies often comprising bundles of ETFs — are ridden with conflicts of interest that undermine one of the hottest and most opaque businesses on Wall Street, a trio of academics argues.

These allocation blueprints, usually created by asset managers and deployed by financial advisers, have exploded in popularity in recent years as easy, one-stop solutions for investors of all stripes.

Yet the firms designing them tend to favor their own exchange-traded funds, Jonathan Brogaard, Nataliya Gerasimova and Ying Liu wrote. And advisers are steering client money to them with seemingly little regard to what that means for performance.

“These affiliated ETFs, on average, have lower past returns and higher fees than unaffiliated funds,” the team said. “We also do not find evidence that the affiliated ETFs provide superior performance after they are recommended.”

These are big claims against a business with ever-growing clout over the billions gushing in and out of ETFs every day. Model portfolio assets have more than doubled over the last five years and Broadridge Financial Solutions projects they can double again to $10 trillion by 2025.

Read more: BlackRock and TwoSigma Quants Size Up the Model Portfolio Boom

Many providers of models are asset managers, who stand to benefit from new cash flowing to their funds. Meanwhile, financial advisers have embraced them as a way to outsource allocation decisions so more time can be spent attracting and serving clients.

Yet investors are hardly innocent victims. Many appear to be blindly following model recommendations and taking little notice of the fees and performance, the paper said.

“Investors who chase the recommendations also behave differently, as they pay less attention to both the price and the performance of the ETFs,” the study found.

Brogaard at the University of Utah, Gerasimova at the Norwegian School of Economics and Liu at the Shanghai University of Finance and Economics tracked the effects of model changes in Morningstar data between 2010 and 2020.

They found that an ETF receives 1.1 percentage point more in flows per month after a recommendation, or inclusion in a model. Demand for the featured products also then becomes less sensitive to fees and past performance.

ETFs owned by the same parent company are a little more than three-times more likely to be added to a model — despite fees that are on average six basis points higher and year-to-date returns 67 basis points lower compared to unaffiliated funds.

The findings are the latest iteration of longstanding worries that major Wall Street firms tend to use one business line to boost another, regardless of cost to the end-investor. Previous studies have found that investing platforms and retirement-plan providers, for instance, favor funds of the same brand.

Anecdotal evidence has been growing for some time over the impact of model portfolios. A number of outsize ETF flows in recent years have been connected to adjustments in large models.

For example, a tweak to one strategy by BlackRock Inc. in July drew a record daily inflow to its ETF of inflation-hedged bonds. The world’s largest asset manager has also added its main ESG fund to its model portfolios, helping fuel $18 billion of inflows in two years.

“As a fiduciary, BlackRock provides model portfolios for advisors designed to meet clients’ investment objectives while controlling for risk in an efficient, cost-effective manner,” a spokesperson said by email. “Our platform offers advisors choice from a wide range of portfolio options which may include iShares ETFs, BlackRock mutual funds and ETFs and funds from third party managers.”

The new paper, titled “Advising the Advisors: Evidence from ETFs,” is among the first to document the sway of these portfolios.

“Despite the increasing number of model recommendations, little is known about how they influence the investment choices of financial advisors,” the academics wrote. “We aim to add to the industry and regulatory debate about the opacity of the model portfolios.”

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

Trending Ideas

Featured Stocks On The Move

Daily Rundown

Top 3 Stocks in Leading Sectors
  • 3 Electric Power Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Hawaiian Electric Industries, Inc. (HE) Hawaiian Electric Industries, Inc. is a holding company that provides electric utility services and financial services in Hawaii. Through its subsidiaries, it supplies... Read More

  • 3 Bank Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Comerica Incorporated (CMA) Comerica Incorporated is a financial services company headquartered in Dallas, Texas, offering a range of banking products and services, including commercial and retail banking, wealth... Read More

  • 3 Machinery Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Alta Equipment Group Inc. (ALTG) Alta Equipment Group Inc. is an integrated equipment dealership platform in the United States, operating through three segments: Material Handling, Construction Equipment, and... Read More

  • 3 Silver Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Gatos Silver, Inc. (GATO) Gatos Silver, Inc. is a precious metals mining company primarily focused on silver and zinc production. Its flagship Cerro Los Gatos mine in Mexico... Read More

  • 3 Metal Production Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Century Aluminum Company (CENX) Century Aluminum Company is a primary aluminum producer, with operations that include the production of high-purity, low-carbon aluminum used in automotive, aerospace, and industrial... Read More

  • 3 Medical Drug Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Limited (TEVA) Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Limited is a global pharmaceutical company specializing in generic and specialty medicines. The company provides a wide range of treatments... Read More

  • 3 Paper Product Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content AptarGroup Inc. (ATR) AptarGroup Inc. is a global leader in providing innovative dispensing and packaging solutions, serving diverse industries like beauty, personal care, and pharmaceuticals. They focus on... Read More

  • 3 Restaurant Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Brinker International, Inc. (EAT) Brinker International, Inc. operates well-known restaurant brands such as Chili’s Grill & Bar and Maggiano’s Little Italy. The company is a leader in the... Read More

  • 3 Investment Brokerage Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Robinhood Markets, Inc. (HOOD) Robinhood Markets, Inc. is a financial services company known for its commission-free trading platform, which allows users to trade stocks, options, cryptocurrencies, and ETFs.... Read More

  • 3 Shipping Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content ZIM Integrated Shipping Services Ltd. (ZIM) ZIM Integrated Shipping Services Ltd. is a global container shipping company that provides cargo transportation services worldwide. The company operates a modern... Read More

  • 3 Mining Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content Perpetua Resources Corp. (PPTA) Perpetua Resources Corp. is a mining company focused on the exploration and redevelopment of the Stibnite Gold Project in Idaho, which is one of... Read More

  • 3 Airline Stocks To Buy Now

    Featured Content General Electric Company (GE) General Electric Company is a global industrial conglomerate with operations spanning sectors such as aviation, healthcare, power, and renewable energy. GE is known for... Read More